Market or Government ? “Boosting” the role of CSR
Published at: 16/02/11
Concept development
261
261
(by Prof. Luciano Barin-Cruz – HEC Montreal)
Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) represents one of the multiple avenues to achieve sustainable development. Although more and more companies engage in actions and discourse associated to CSR, there is no consensus whether CSR must be a matter of government imposition or of companies’ volunteer initiative.
Coerced CSR refers to a regulated or imposed type of CSR. Usually, it is associated with legislation and the role of government enforcing companies to achieve minimum social and environmental standards. As opposed, Strategic CSR refers to integrate social and environmental projects in company’s value chain in order to create value or competitive advantages. It is about innovation and the possibility to create new environmental and social friendly projects that may differentiate the company in a certain sector.
We believe that a balance between these two types of CSR may be searched. On the one hand, Coerced CSR guarantees the government role as the institution that represents society and defines which actions may be undertaken. The challenge here is to consider the specificities of each sector and of each region. The complexity of our social, environmental and economic problems call for adapted legislations and standards. On the other hand, Strategic CSR guarantees innovation and boost companies to keep creating new projects that can reduce environmental impact and improve social life conditions in many regions. The challenge is to avoid paternalist approaches in which some companies replace governments in some local regions and start to decide when and how to provide social programs.
In sum, the search for this balance between coerced and strategic CSR represents a huge challenge for our society. It requires political commitment from politicians, companies and civil society. It also calls for individual engagement in different levels in order to think for the collectivity, to adapt our needs and to change our mindset. Are we ready?
Source: Professor Luciano Barin-Cruz - HEC Montréal
Expertise:
* Corporate Social Responsibility
* Sustainability
* Relations between Developed and Emergent Countries
The theoretical approach behind this article is valid and I love the thinking behind it all. However, the point to realise is that there is a need for SOMEONE to take an action. In the case of CSR, the businesses are not going to make the shift till they see a need to do so. This may be via competition, or my initial 'encouragement' from the government. Thus, while the balance between the coercive measures is integral, there is a need for the government to pass some legislations or indirect motivation to help businesses take the step in the right direction.
The theoretical approach behind this article is valid and I love the thinking behind it all. However, the point to realise is that there is a need for SOMEONE to take an action. In the case of CSR, the businesses are not going to make the shift till they see a need to do so. This may be via competition, or my initial 'encouragement' from the government. Thus, while the balance between the coercive measures is integral, there is a need for the government to pass some legislations or indirect motivation to help businesses take the step in the right direction.
Je partage de la même position de Suzanne. Les gouvernements des tous les pays doivent non seulement imposer les restrictions et les normes mais aussi effectuer vraiment la fiscalisation et appliquer amandes. Mais les entreprises doivent prendre l’initiative pour que leurs affaires soient socialement responsables. Spécialement celles des secteurs minières et pétrolières.
Dans le cas d'entreprises qui ont des comportements socialement IRRESPONSABLES, comme certaines entreprises minières qui opèrent dans des pays africains, par exemple, je dirais que le gouvernement doit imposer certaines restrictions, normes. Mais le changement sera réel quand les entreprises prendront l'intiative d'être socialement responsables..... il y a encore du chemin à parcourir pour y parvenir
Comme le dit le professeur Barin-Cruz tous ont un rôle à jouer dans ce domaine. Il importe dès à présent de s'assurer que les politiques soient de plus ne plus sensibilisés à cette question. Des initiatives telles que celle de la SG est un pas dans cette direction.
@ Pierri - Obrigado pelo apoio
Jonny, Parabens pelo trabalho!! Boa sorte!! abs
Jonathan - merci des vos commentaires.
@ Luiz – Le Development Durable est une action transversale (comme Claude l’a précise dans un autre de nos posts), donc tous les acteurs de la société doivent s’engager et prendre des actions concrètes pour qu’on puisse avoir une société soit vraiment soutenable.
Je suis tout à fait d’accord avec le professeur Luciano Barin-Cruz. Nous pouvons réussi à avoir une société soutenable s’il aura le vrai engagement des politiciens, des entreprises privés et du gouvernement et de la société en général. Et, je crois qu’une grande partie de nous est déjà prête…
Nice text from professor Luciano. To answer his question: NO, we are not ready yet. As the group presented in the “CSR is dead” article, companies are not ready to assume their shared responsibility. So, in my opinion we still need “legislation and the role of government enforcing companies to achieve minimum social and environmental standards”
I loved this article. At the beginning, I tended to support coercive measures to frame business action to avoid unethical procedures, potential failures and security risks. After reading the text, I realised that coercion leads to compliance decisions and thus to standardized management practices. By combining Coerced with CSR Strategic CSR, companies will be able to continue creating innovative new responsible projects adapted to what is socially acceptable.